Can Dividend Investors Find Value In Mercury General Corporation (NYSE: MCY) Stock?


Mercury General Corporation (NYSE: MCY) is currently paying investors an above average dividend yield of 5.3% while the Financials sector median stands at 2.2%. Even though this makes Mercury General look attractive relative to its peers, it’s useful to understand the company’s future dividend potential. Will Mercury General’s bottom line be the main catalyst driving future growth or maybe its payout ratio? Understanding these components and how they impact value may change your mind on the company’s future prospects.

Is A Dividend Analysis Appropriate?

Dividend Discount Model (DDM) is a way of valuing a company based on the theory that a stock is worth the discounted sum of all of its future dividend payments.

However, before walking through my dividend analysis for Mercury General, it’s first helpful to determine if this is actually an appropriate technique to be used when estimating its fair value. Many analysts are often biased towards one specific valuation approach which is typically a mistake that can negatively impact investment decisions and result in trading losses or missed opportunities. Every company has unique characteristics that may require you to adjust your analysis.

Understanding leverage trends is the first step when determining what valuation analyses are relevant for a given company. When a company’s leverage doesn’t fluctuate or is expected to remain stable over time, then an equity valuation model (e.g. equity DCF, DDM) will be the most appropriate valuation technique. The reason for this is because when leverage is stable, interest expense on debt can typically be projected with much more reliability.

How do we check if a company’s leverage has been fluctuating or is expected to do so? This isn’t always straightforward but checking recent debt ratio trends can be a good indicator. Mercury General’s debt to equity ratio has stayed relatively stable over last few years hitting a low of 15.9% in December 2015 and a high of 22.1% in March 2018. This suggests that an equity valuation model is a suitable technique when valuing the company’s shares. Now does it make sense to use a dividend discount model knowing that an equity valuation technique is an appropriate methodology?

We now must determine if Mercury General pays a dividend and if so, is its payout ratio relatively high (typically above 70%)? This helps figure out if the company distributes the majority of its profits to shareholders in the form of dividends.

Mercury General Payout Ratio Table

Source: Mercury General dividend discount model

Mercury General paid out a total of $138 million in cash dividends to shareholders in its most recent fiscal year Dec-17 representing a payout ratio of 95.2%. Therefore, it is fitting to use a dividend discount model when calculating the intrinsic value of Mercury General stock.

How To Project Mercury General’s Dividends

Since forecasting dividends directly can be difficult, the first step in building a dividend discount model is to project net income. So let’s create a net income forecast for the next five years and use that as the basis for our future dividends.

Applying consensus estimates, Wall Street is projecting a healthy growth rate in the company’s bottom-line over the next five years. Net income is expected to grow at an average annual rate of 19% bringing net income to $344 million by fiscal year 2022.

Mercury General Net Income Growth Chart

Source: Mercury General Projected Net Income Growth

I apply the net profit estimates above to drive my dividend forecast. The next step is to project the company’s payout ratio. In my estimates shown in the table below, I select a 90.0% payout ratio in 2018 and hold it steady there throughout the remainder of my projection period.

Mercury General Dividend Forecast

Source: Mercury General dividend discount model

Discounting Mercury General’s Future Dividends

The final step is to present value the forecasted dividend distributions using a discount rate. I used’s Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) model to help arrive at an estimate for the company’s cost of equity.

I concluded a reasonable cost of equity for the company to be 9.7% at the midpoint. Although I don’t walk you through the CAPM assumptions that got me there, you can view the calculations using real-time data at’s Mercury General WACC model page.

Mercury General Dividend Fair Value Conclusion

In conclusion, my dividend discount model calculates a fair value per share for Mercury General of $63.57, 34.3% above its current stock price of $47.34. MCY appears to be an undervalued stock based on the company’s future dividend potential alone. Therefore, now may be a good time to purchase shares or increase your position in the company.

What This Means For Investors

An important component of the dividend discount model that investors should understand is that the technique will inherently undervalue a stock. This is typically the result of the payout ratio assumption being less than 100% implying some cash leakage. Meaning the approach does not capture value that would otherwise build up as cash on the balance sheet. In practice, this excess retained cash is usually paid out to shareholders as special dividends or to make up for cash shortfalls for future dividends during economic downturns.

Understanding that this approach calculates a conservative intrinsic value estimate is a very promising sign for investors searching for an entry point to buy the stock. Shares of Mercury General currently appear to be undervalued based on its future dividend potential alone. This means that MCY may have significantly more upside than what I’ve calculated above.

Although a dividend discount model on its own is not necessarily indicative of a stock’s fair value, it does offer a number of useful insights. This valuation should only be the start of your analysis in relation to your total research. I recommend that you continue your review of Mercury General to gain a better understanding of its underlying fundamentals.

As of this writing, I did not hold a position in any of the aforementioned securities and this is not a buy or sell recommendation on any security mentioned.

Expertise: Valuation, financial statement analysis. Matt Hogan is also a co-founder of His expertise is in investment decision making. Prior to, Matt worked for an investment banking group providing fairness opinions in connection to stock acquisitions. He spent much of his time building valuation models to help clients determine an asset’s fair value. He believes that these same valuation models should be used by all investors before buying or selling a stock. His work is frequently published at InvestorPlace, Benzinga, ValueWalk, AAII, Barron’s, Seeking Alpha and Matt can be reached at or at +1 (516) 778-6257.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.